Bluegill at Brookville Lake

When Fishing at Brookville Lake Proper Tackle & Bait are Important.

  1. Hook sizes from No. 6 to No. 10 (long shank hooks)
  2. The most common baits are worms and night crawlers because they are readily available and bluegill love them. The key is to use only a piece of a worm—just enough to cover the hook. Other productive baits include crickets, grasshoppers, red wrigglers and meal worms. Artificial lures also work well for bluegill. Some of the best lures are black jigs (1/32 ounce and smaller) and tiny spinners. Small flies and poppers are very effective and can be used while fly fishing or in conjunction with a bobber for easy casting (also see fly fishing)

Location of Bluegill in Brookville Lake Depending on the Season

Using the proper tackle, bait and technique is critical in catching bluegill, but it is important to know where to find bluegill in Brookville Lake, depending on the season. Because bluegill use different habitats at different times of the year, the best locations in spring probably won’t be as good in late summer or winter.

  • Spring & Early Summer at Brookville Lake

    —Bluegill spawn in spring and early summer, and this is a good time to catch them. When water temperatures exceed 70F, begin looking for spawning bluegill in shallow water. The tell-tale “elephant tracks”—groups of nearly round craters that mark spawning nests—will give away their location. Once you find a spawning colony, take care not to spook the bluegill as you fish. Cast beyond the nests and retrieve your bait through the colony. Male bluegill will guard nests against intruders and will aggressively take small lures.

  • Late summer at Brookville Lake

    —You can readily catch bluegill after the spawning season, when they move into deeper water as summer progresses. In summer, bluegill can be found along the edges of weed beds, around brush piles, stake-beds and flooded timber, especially if deeper water is nearby. Bluegill are commonly found in water more than 10 feet deep in summer and typically hang just above the thermocline (the depth where water temperature changes dramatically and below which oxygen levels are usually low). Best fishing is usually in the morning and evening when the fish are most active.

  • Fall at Brookville Lake

    —Look for bluegill in the same locations as late summer and also fish shallower water near weed beds, brush or other types of cover. While morning and evening are the best times to fish during summer, midday fishing success often improves as water cools in the fall.

  • Winter at Brookville Lake

    —Look for bluegill in water 12 to 20 feet deep. They school near underwater structures, usually near the bottom. Bluegill do not feed as actively in winter, so be sure to use small baits and slow presentation. Using light tackle and line is also essential because bluegill bite very lightly in winter, and these bites would go undetected with less sensitive tackle.

“Core content provided by Missouri Department of Conservation.”

Interested in Advertising With Us?

We are pleased to provide hundreds of thousands of tourists with an easy-to-use website and weekly lake reports to stay up-to-date with all the news in the area. You have multiple opportunities to be featured in front of these prospective clients! is the premier location for planning your SE Indiana vacation.

Get Lake Connected with clear, relevant information before your next vacation!



Lake Connected